A jar of the Punctilious Mr. P's hot pepper jelly on a marble tabletop with a porcelain tea cup and saucer, and cracker in the background A jar of the Punctilious Mr. P's hot pepper jelly on a marble tabletop with trader joe's 'cracker assortment' and creamy herb chevre cheese A jar of the Punctilious Mr. P's hot pepper jelly on a marble tabletop with trader joe's 'cracker assortment' and creamy herb chevre cheese A jar of the Punctilious Mr. P's hot pepper jelly on a marble tabletop with trader joe's 'cracker assortment' and creamy herb chevre cheese Mr. P's Jams and jellies pair perfectly with Trader Joe's cracker assortment
A jar of the Punctilious Mr. P's hot pepper jelly on a marble tabletop with a porcelain tea cup and saucer, and cracker in the background
A jar of the Punctilious Mr. P's hot pepper jelly on a marble tabletop with trader joe's 'cracker assortment' and creamy herb chevre cheese
A jar of the Punctilious Mr. P's hot pepper jelly on a marble tabletop with trader joe's 'cracker assortment' and creamy herb chevre cheese
A jar of the Punctilious Mr. P's hot pepper jelly on a marble tabletop with trader joe's 'cracker assortment' and creamy herb chevre cheese
Mr. P's Jams and jellies pair perfectly with Trader Joe's cracker assortment

Mr. P's Hot Pepper Jelly

Gourmet Foods by The Punctilious Mr. P's Place Card Co.

$21.00

The Punctilious Mr. P's Anthemion palmette logo

The Punctilious Mr. P's Pantry logo
Friendship in a jar.™

Carpe Diem

Discover the irresistible flavor of Mr. P's Hot Pepper Jelly, where sweetness meets a fiery kick. This small-batch creation adds a thrilling burst of excitement to your palate, perfect for pairing with cheeses like brie, goat, or blue. It also serves as a captivating glaze for your favorite proteins, enhancing their flavors with a touch of adventure. Carpe diem with every dollop of this bold and unforgettable jelly.

Experience the ultimate flavor adventure with Mr. P's Hot Pepper Jelly. Made in small batches, this unique blend combines sweet and spicy notes to create a taste sensation like no other. Add a dash of excitement to your dishes, whether it's a cheese platter or a protein glaze. Embrace the bold flavors that seize the day and elevate your culinary experiences.

Mr. P's Hot Pepper Jelly is the perfect hostess gift! Send it on ahead of your arrival and be the favorite guest.

Five All Natural Ingredients

  • cane sugar, peppers (sweet & chili), cider vinegar, pectin, citric acid

  • See details in tabs below for additional info

• Made in small gallon batches, by hand, and tastes like you had the time to make it yourself. Made in Old Chatham, in the heart of New York's Hudson River Valley.

• Did you know that you can now order Menu Cards and Buffet Tags to coordinate with your place cards!

  • Vegan
  • Gluten Free
  • No artificial colors or flavors
  • No artificial sweeteners
  • Size
  • 11 oz (312 grams)

Mr. P's Hot Pepper Jelly perfectly pairs with...

  • Trader Joe's Creamy Herb Chevre goat cheese, Brie, Sharp Cheddar, Gouda, Manchego, or Blue cheese
  • Trader Joe's 'Cracker Assortment'

Shelf Life

  • Unopened: 24 months
  • Open & Refrigerated: 3 months
  • Made in small gallon batches, by hand.
  • We aim to ship your order from our workshop in Old Chatham, New York in 10 days. Please order early enough to receive your items for your event.
  • Once your order ships, timely delivery is now the responsibility of the shipper.
  • You also control the speed (and cost) of shipping when you choose your preferred shipping method at checkout. If you need something overnight, please don't choose Ground. You can learn more about our shipping tips and shipping policy.
  • Due to the nature of food, NO RETURNS unless in error by us.

Customer Reviews

Based on 1 review Write a review
More information View images

You may also like

Recently viewed

Featured collection

Collection's name

Product's name

$30.00

Product's name

$30.00

Product's name

$30.00

Product's name

$30.00
View all products